Friday, February 25, 2005

Missing Nuclides: A Challenge to Young Earth Creationism

Below you will find a table sourced from the book "The Age of the Earth" (Table 8.3) that provides strong evidence against a recent or young age of the Earth. You'll see that nuclides with half-lives less than 80 Ma that are not produced by natural processes cannot be found in nature. Since all of these can be produced through nucleosynthesis the reasonable explanation is that these nuclides have simply decayed over the 4.5 billion years that the Earth has existed.


Nuclide Half-life (years) Found in Nature
50V 6 x 10^15 yes
144Nd 2.4 x 10^15 yes
174Hf 2.0 x 10^15 yes
192Pt ~1 x 10^15 yes
115In 6 x 10^14 yes
152Gd 1.1 x 10^14 yes
123Te 1.2 x 10^13 yes
190Pt 6.9 x 10^11 yes
138La 1.12 x 10^11 yes
147Sm 1.06 x 10^11 yes
87Rb 4.88 x 10^10 yes
187Re 4.3 x 10^10 yes
176Lu 3.5 x 10^10 yes
232Th 1.40 x 10^10 yes
238U 4.47 x 10^9 yes
40K 1.25 x 10^9 yes
235U 7.02 x 10^8 yes
244Pu 8.2 x 10^7 yes
146Sm 7 x 10^7 no
205Pb 3.0 x 10^7 no
236U 2.39 x 10^7 yes - but continually produced by natural processes or man
129I 1.7 x 10^7 yes - but continually produced by natural processes or man
247Cm 1.6 x 10^7 no
182Hf 9 x 10^6 no
107Pd ~7 x 10^6 yes - but continually produced by natural processes or man
135Cs 3.0 x 10^6 no
97Tc 2.6 x 10^6 no
237Np 2.14 x 10^6 yes - but continually produced by natural processes or man
150Gd 2.1 x 10^6 no
10Be 1.6 x 10^6 yes - but continually produced by natural processes or man
93Zr 1.5 x 10^6 no
98Tc 1.5 x 10^6 no
154Dy ~1 x 10^6 no